Monday, January 28, 2008

Is this Malaysia....?

I was browsing through You Tube and came upon this footage of a raid. No information on the parties involved or by which group of authorities conducting this raid. Neither is there a date, time or place mentioned nor can I authenticate .....but I'm shocked and disgusted by the display of violence involved and the recording itself...if it was for real !

You decide if you are in favor of such practises by both the couple (for khalwat) and the raiding authorities..... as for me... I'm speechless !

18 comments:

Anonymous said...

Saw the clip some times ago. To put things in the right perspective, the couple was caught by the husband of the woman and his friends. My understanding was they were later handed to authorities. Having the act caught on films and later displayed to public is a different issue and I guess one will come up with pros and cons. But to jump into conclusions and blaming "authorities" I believe is uncalled for.

HARD-T (Ori) said...

Actually this video clip was made when this couple (female is the wife of somebody) cought in a house - making love - with her stranger. I had seen this video clip for the last 4 month. There is no authorities involved but her husban and his friends take theri own action. This action happen some where in Kedah or Perlis (base on their slanka). And this is real happen.

Shanghai Fish said...

Tok and hard-t,
Like I said earlier I have no way to authenticate this video but my stand is the same...do we need this kind of brutal violence to solve a problem ?
thanks for the input though!Battering is an offence !Unless you want to follow the law of the jungle !Remember we are a civilised society.....right ?

Anonymous said...

The way I see it, this man was probably at the place having a massage treatment done, and the lady could well be the masseuse. Take note of the "hot stone" (metallic) at the scene, which is a common "tool" used by masseuse to remove "angin" from the body. Furthermore, the lady was well dressed up and the man was wrapped in towel.

Anonymous said...

HardT must be a psychic to pinpoint where this video scene was made based on the slang being spoken, and also could guess that one of those fellas is the lady's husband. I am impressed.

Maybe Tok heard the correct news about the husband's involvement in the assault, but could it be the wife was secretly working as a masseuse to help put some extra food on the family table.

Anonymous said...

Based on the accompanying stories (when I view the clips earlier) posted by the clip uploader) I am almost certain that my earlier posting and hard T is correct. And it is from the northen state.
On your stand on so called "brutal violence", let me just put it this way, if you were to caught your spouse in the situation like this, what would you do? Don't ask me my reaction coz' I wouldn't want to even think of being caught in such a position myself.
Of course, as I said earlier, the act of putting the act on tape and displayed it to public is still debatable.

HARD-T (Ori) said...

I agree what Tok said. The VC title is 'Kantoi Ngan Bini Orang'. I have a lots of VC that show 'macam-macam lah' even sexs among our school, college and university student. And on what Shanghaifish ask: do we need this kind of brutal violence to solve a problem?
My answer is: Yes if that happen to me.

Djnascimanto said...

It was in Langkawi. She was caught by her husband and his friends. Happened 5 months ago.

Anonymous said...

Hoi cina

I can't see your video and probaly do not like anything high handed from authority. I do not like and it is not yr biz to meddle into muslim affair. You have no right to talk or express anything on muslim affairs. The constitution is very clear there.

If you do not agree with constitution, it means you do not agree with the social contract that bestow you or your forefather citizenship. You are welcome to express your disagreement by rescinding yr citizenship.

Walaupun British buat tekanan dan paksaan, bukan British yang kasi kau kerakyatan. Sedarlah menumpang negara orang. Tak suka cara orang, kau boleh blah.

If you are anglophilic, you can go to England but if you are an Ah Beng-type, go back to China. Heard it is more prosperous there. If you are neither, you can go jump in the South China Sea!

Anonymous said...

Tok is perhaps correct to a certain extent, those jokers took the law into their own hands and bashed the couple after caughting them red-handed.

Here it is a tic for tac kinda thing & luckily there didn't resort to something worse like torture, murder, etc.

The bullies were doing it out of anger, jealousy and vengence as I believe anybody could also go into such a state, if there's no mercy and forgiveness in heart.

Anonymous said...

Hi Nusantara Melayu

Peace brother. No need to write like this. If you can blog that means you use your brain more than your brawn. To err is human to forgive is divine. Smile and have a nice day brother.

holytounge said...

.....agree with tok and hard-t on this.....

Anonymous said...

Who is this Nusantara Melayu coming in and hurling racist remarks ?

Perhaps he thought that Shanghaifish is a Chinese fellow so thats why he called Cina... he he he... dumb ass.

Anyway his language proves that he's a real racist, insensitive and 'jump the gun' type of person.

muststopthis said...

aiyo....and that is why we are still in this state of disarray....
Nusantara melayu , obviously you do not know about plug ins! try to google more to know about it, then perhaps you will then know why you could not watch the video.

As for commenting about islamic affair , err, pleas feel free to point out which part of THE Constitution!

Its thanks to Morons like you that is causing this country great disunity! Hoi, first think as a Malaysian! then as a Muslim.....you wanker!

amoker said...

Stephen,
I was once a group of kampung folks beat up a teenager who stole a motorbike. It is similar to this clip with flying kicks and everthing. They even use the motorbike helmet to beat the chap on the head with huge thuds. I was eating at the Malay stall and was the first person to shout for the guys to stop. Then the makciks in the stall then did the same to stop the attack.Police came after that.

Dear Nusantara Melayu,
I prob 'save' one of your kind, but for me I was shouting out for a fellow malaysian.( actually did not know if the chap survive the attack) The rule of law should govern us, not rule of riots.Please read up more things about the constitution and even the origin of Malays ( read Michael Crick's good writeup)

M. Bakri Musa said...

You should e-mail this to our KSU Sidek Hassan: sidek@pmo.gov.my.
He has been bragging about his reforms on the civil service.
I wished I could email it myself. but I cannot seem to get it on youtube.
M. Bakri Musa

Anonymous said...

Muslim or not, a Human Being and so have Rights!
-----------------------
All react with concerns why anyone should be violently acted!
Should the problem be handled with law instead of force?
To handle the problem not because it was seen but what was the cause behind the scene!
These are all about civilization which should lead not only People but also religion if Human are to be concerned!
When Human are constituents of Religion and not the reverse!
Come to blog to share civilization and be concerned if anything bully!

Anonymous said...

Astaghfirullah. Our Prophet Sallallahu alaihi wa sallam would not have wanted to see an unmarried or adulterous couple in a room, but he Sallallahu alaihi wasallam would have given them many chances before inflicting punishment upon them, as is evidenced by the many ahaadith on the subject. La Hawla wa La Quwwata illa bilLah.